Sunday, December 16, 2018

Review: Making Up Your Own Mind: Thinking Effectively Through Creative Puzzle-Solving

Making Up Your Own Mind: Thinking Effectively Through Creative Puzzle-Solving Making Up Your Own Mind: Thinking Effectively Through Creative Puzzle-Solving by Edward Burger
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Early in a semester, I like to pose to my college algebra students:
Jack is looking at Anne, but Anne is looking at George. Jack is married, but George is not. Is a married person looking at an unmarried person?
This is from the 2010 book What Intelligence Tests Miss: The Psychology of Rational Thought by Keith E Stanovich. From the same book I suggest to the students that they apply “fully disjunctive reasoning”, a phrase I find is a koan-like tool for disruption of quick, reactive thought and nudging students into thinking of categories as a movement toward proof construction. During this time, we work in logic leaving strictly mathematical topics aside. Such exercises in critical thinking are also germane to this text and can be of benefit to students of mathematics, philosophy, engineering, and, well, life. The promotion line here is, “How you can become better at solving real-world problems by learning creative puzzle-solving skills.” […]

[Look for my entire review at MAA Reviews]

View all my reviews

Saturday, December 15, 2018

Review: Moral Scepticism and Moral Knowledge

Moral Scepticism and Moral Knowledge Moral Scepticism and Moral Knowledge by Renford Bambrough
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I want to read more and think more deeply about philosophy, but sometimes it feels like reading occasionally -- without making a career of it -- is nearly fruitless. I got a little intimidated on this one, off the bat dropping experts' terms like nomos and phusis... But, I eased into the short study which I feel is open to laymen like myself.

So, regardless of whether you believe or are convinced by the author's arguments, this is a good, concise survey of objectivist and subjectivist approaches to morality from the ancients (Aristotle) to contemporaries. The author is on one side of the fence and this work is an argument for objectivism via

...a direct proof of the objectivity of morals, and hence to undertake to show that the familiar arguments for moral subjectivism, however popular and persuasive, are necessarily ill-founded.


I tend to feel leery of objectivism in many epistemological areas, especially something that feels metaphysical to me, such as morality. However, I came to this book directly after reading Report on Planet Three and Other Speculations and Clarke armed me with the open-mindedness to consider beyond the expected senses. We have more than the five senses. There's a sense of balance for instance. Why not a sense of morality? That does not lead to an absolute interpretation of right and wrong. After all, among the sighted, not all those that see a painting will agree to its beauty. So, if an objective reality is one that we can detect and compare aspects from any our "sense", maybe I can agree to an objective reality for morality ... in that "sense" (I am not repeating an argument of the author's, but this may be the closest thing to an original idea in philosophy that I have conjured up, ever.)

Indeed, I think one of my main reasons for reluctance to embrace and objectivist view of morality -- and I guess then placing me in the realm of "moral scepticism" the author refutes here -- is that it feeds into a threatening equation: morality + objectivism = absolute truth in so many human minds. Indeed, that is acknowledtged here by quoting others, including

...P. H. Nowell-Smith when he remarks that 'It is no accident that religious persecutions are the monopoly of objective theorists' (Ethics, p. 47).


To put it another way, I find it difficult to consider or discuss the epistemology of morality with such investigations careening off inot the morass of determining morality.

Though we are concerned here with abstract issues of epistemology, they are directly relevant to substantive moral issues, as can be shown by an example which also serves as a first step towards the positive characterisation of morality that we are seeking. It is a true story of an incident at an American university some years ago. A graduate student was expelled from the university, and it was believed by other students that he had been expelled for living with a woman student on the campus. At once there was a protest parade with banners declaring that 'Morality is a matter of private choice'. Later it was rumoured that the expulsion had been imposed as a penalty for gross and persistent blackmail of a member of the faculty. The protest died: there were no banners proclaiming that 'Blackmail is a matter of private choice'.


Certainly an enlightening anecdote.

Further than all this, the author makes some throught-provoking arguments for fitting in the moralistic "ought" in the logicians' expressions of proposotions and implication.

Overall, a quick and worthy read in this area. I am surprised the author's approachable writing is not more widely known.

View all my reviews

Review: Report on Planet Three and Other Speculations

Report on Planet Three and Other Speculations Report on Planet Three and Other Speculations by Arthur C. Clarke
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

It is amazing how well, even before the moon landing and the Space Age in general, Clarke's speculative essays hold up for remarkable insight and being a joy to read. The initial, title piece I recall reading as a youth (perhaps in a different anthology) and still the point of view of imagined Martians seeing our rust-inducing atmosphere rich in oxygen and water vapor as a dangerous environment that may preclude much life. This type of point of view reframing I think is beyond entertaining -- it is enlightening. That is the most overtly science fiction contribution. Mostly what we have here is lectures and articles written imaging the future, where Clarke foresaw the internet, wireless communications, etc.: "During the next decade we will see coming into the home a general purpose communications console comprising TV screen, camera, microphone, computer keyboard and hardcopy readout device."

Some of the things he perceived campe to pass by this publishing and postscripts and introductions touch on the accuracy (such as $10 billion to reach the Moon, compare at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_...) and even inaccuracy.

There is some very good mental exercise here in the reframing Clarke uses and the Zen koan-like interruptions to linear thought that he employs, such as bringing in a discussion of the painting "The Blind Girl" and the poem "Blind" by Harry Kemp to illustrate how diffent the experiuence can be for alien life able to see ultraviolet, feel magnetism, etc.


View all my reviews

Review: The Secret Holocaust Diaries

The Secret Holocaust Diaries The Secret Holocaust Diaries by Nonna Bannister
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

The title may make many to expect the memoir of a Jewish concentration camp survivor. This life story is actually a bit different path through the horrors of the Holocaust and their precursors. It is actually a biography of a childhood starting from warmth and security in the well-to-do family of royalist supporters after the fall of the czars and the rise of Bolshevism. Fond Christmas memories and early indoor toilets is cut short by Hitler's incursion into the Ukraine. At this point, Nonna and her parents have two enemies: the Nazis and the Stalinists that see them as implicit collaborators for not withdrawing ahead of the advance of the Wehrmacht. Nonna details a couple of times her childhood memory of Red Army planes strafing Ukrainian citizens. The intensity of the fear of Stalinist reprisal is seen from the fact that after leaving her brother and losing her father, boarding a train to go work in the Third Reich with the retreating Germans is actually seens as the wisest option. The work camp is hellacious and Nonna's mother has her painting and piano playing skills extracted out of her until, after having her arms and fingers broken at Ravensbrück concentration camp she was killed there. Apparently, this sharp turn into the lethal Holocaust machine was caused by her attempts to save a Jewish baby on that ill-fated train ride.

Through astute awareness and a gift for languages, Nonna survives the work camp and the war, largely thanks to crippling diseases which places her in the care of nuns who protect her first from the Nazis, then the vengeful Russians.

This audiobook edition includes moving interviews with Nonna's son and husband as well late '90s audio of Nonna relating some of her Holocaust experiences to her family.

View all my reviews

Wednesday, December 12, 2018

Review: If You Like the Beatles...: Here Are Over 200 Bands, Films, Records and Other Oddities That You Will Love

If You Like the Beatles...: Here Are Over 200 Bands, Films, Records and Other Oddities That You Will Love If You Like the Beatles...: Here Are Over 200 Bands, Films, Records and Other Oddities That You Will Love by Bruce Pollock
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

Pollock uses the vast world of The Beatles as a springboard to tell the story of pop and rock from roots of the Beatles through the quartet's arc to the faintest echoes in modern rock. At times the book is a mash-up of unsynthesized trivia but I enjoyed as a quick read that was at times an exhilirating, breathless jaunt through decades of memorable music.

My interview with the author is at https://archive.org/details/BrucePoll...

View all my reviews

Monday, December 10, 2018

Review: The Shadow President: The Truth About Mike Pence

The Shadow President: The Truth About Mike Pence The Shadow President: The Truth About Mike Pence by Michael D'Antonio
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

A very revealing, even penetrating political biography of this muted leader from the evangelical far-right. The title makes Pence sound like a new Karl Rove, but really he comes across as fawning lackey lapdog to Trump in order to advance such fundamentalist goals expected to be in line with his action as Governor of Indiana when he signed bills intended to restrict abortions and the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. (With RFRA, he encountered fierce resistance from moderate members of his party, sports associates, the business community, and LGBT advocates. The backlash against the RFRA led Pence to amend the bill to prohibit discrimination based on sexual orientation, gender identity, and other criteria.)

View all my reviews

Friday, December 7, 2018

Review: Man in Full

Man in Full Man in Full by Tom Wolfe
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I give four stars for such a readable, large novel: it read fast and easy as half its nearly eight hundred pages. Also bolstering my high esteem is the core plot element as stoicism as a real-world philosophy to find sanity and calm in high and low places, drawing heavily on (with quotations) from The Stoic and Epicurean Philosophers: The Complete Extant Writings of Epicurus, Epictetus, Lucretius and Marcus Aurelius by Whitney J. Oates.

I can't go five stars for the unsubtle irony of Conrad as carer to Conrad, etc. the pulling off the shelf of such a deus ex machina as an earthquake and prisoner-passing-as-soldier.

Finally, while Wolfe has (no surprise) pitch-perfect depiction of white southern dialect and phrasing, his courageous leap in black dialect -- including rap lyrics -- falses short of sounding real and is instead even cartoonish at times.

View all my reviews

Review: Outsight: Poetry

Outsight: Poetry by Tom Schulte My rating: 3 of 5 stars I'm the author, so I am not going to brag. I...