The Psychoanalytic Movement by
Ernest Gellner
My rating:
0 of 5 stars
This edition is part of the Paladin Movements and Ideas nonfiction book series published in the mid-1980s by the British imprint Paladin Books (part of Granada Publishing, later Grafton Books). Edited by
Justin Wintle, the series offers concise, accessible surveys of major philosophical, psychological, political, and artistic movements written by prominent scholars.
A thesis of modern ills needing a new, supernatural explanation and causes to commune with; a "secular religion" in psychoanalysis.
There is every indication that this realm of human relationships has taken over that overwhelming load of anxiety and sense of precariousness which had once attached to the natural world. This realm now has a peculiar quality which once characterized the natural world (but apparently does so no longer): a sense of tight pattern, of lurking danger and fatality, which at the same time cannot be apprehended or controlled by rational and intelligible methods. The realm of nature had once been endowed with this compelling feel, for most or all of our ancestors in the agrarian age; but nature has been tamed, and we now really see that it is subject to intelligible and impersonal laws, whether or not each of us individually knows just what they are and how they are to be applied.
By contrast, the realm of personal relations, which has now become the area of our most pressing concern, the sphere in which we stand to lose and fear most, does have just this particular feel about it: it seems anything but random, and the pattern of experiences which befall various people generally has an air of some kind of hidden and ineluctable logic about it - yet at the same time, attempts to seize, capture and utilize this logic for our ends, are totally unavailing. The popular psychology self-help magazines and manuals, which do a good trade by promising to fill this gap and to allay these anxieties, do not contain any genuine knowledge or information not already available to common sense; and the generalizations offered, by them or common sense or academic psychology, are riddled with evasion, exceptions, ambiguity, and have little real value. Yet a vacuum must be filled. People find it impossible to remain passive in the face of acute and recurrent anxiety. What is to be done?
...
... Terror has not vanished from the earth, but has merely assumed a new form. Modern life in affluent societies, though accompanied by a sense of secure material well-being, is notoriously riddled with other anxieties anxieties which were not wholly absent in the past, but which those who lived in physically less comfortable ages could not afford to place at the very centre of their attention. These new anxieties now force themselves on us, and not merely because we have been freed from our earlier fears. They have also become more pressing for good objective reasons.
Modern society is or tends to be mobile, fluid, egalitarian and liberal, incomparably more so than most large and complex societies in the past. The price of this liberation from forcibly and/or ideologically ascribed identities, statuses, rituals, practices, employments and family links, is, notoriously, a sense of disorientation and insecurity, for which a variety of thinkers has coined a wide range of terms: alienation, disenchantment, and anomie are perhaps the most celebrated. The disorientation contains, among other things, at least three important elements: first, the material environment has been largely replaced by a social environment, consisting not of things but of people; second, this crucial social or human environment has no stable or reliable structure, and everything in it is uncertain and up for grabs; and third, there is no widely shared and seriously accepted ideology or vision, which could decree how things should properly be arranged. ...
Implicitly, we can find as effective and cheaper solace and balms in deep consideration of philosophy. "Philosophers have only tried to understand the world; the point is to endow one's understanding with a ritual and a promise of salvation."
Freudian analysis is seen as the root in the way somethin like the Catholic Church is closer to the origin of all Christian denominations. (The author sees Freud building on an incoherent Nietzsche.) Revealing free-association and other confessional techniques in front of a priest-like psychoanalysts engenders loyalty-building transference cohering the patient to the institution like a religious adherent.
In this takedown of the talking cure and piercing the veil into the unconscious is a clever neologism. "Cagoulotomy" is a satirical, fictional surgical term coined by Gellner in this book. It does not refer to a real medical procedure. Gellner invents a humorous scenario in which people wear a tight, restrictive hood (a cagoule) that blocks their vision and causes them to crash into others. He describes cagoulotomy as the expensive, drawn-out "cagoule-removing operation" offered by a monopolistic agency whose practitioners make evasive promises about how long the removal will take. Through this allegory, Gellner mocks the institutions, high costs, and open-ended timelines of traditional psychoanalysis.
The cagoule-removing operation is not only mildly expensive, it is also somewhat protracted and energy-absorbing, and some nasty sceptical people have suggested that its efficacy is questionable, and indeed its practitioners themselves seem a bit shifty and evasive when making definite promises about the timing of cagoulotomy, but what of all that?
Another fun allusion is the chapter title "Pirandello Effect". The Italian dramatist Luigi Pirandello (1867–1936) dealt in metafiction and metatheatre exposing the apparatus of a play, film, or story so the audience becomes aware of its constructed nature. A classic example is Pirandello’s
Six Characters in Search of an Author (1921), where fictional characters interrupt a rehearsal to demand their story be staged. He is also known for giving a character the uncanny feel of a real person caught inside a script or role they cannot escape. Literary critic Harold Bloom used the phrase for Hamlet, noting that Hamlet can seem like an actual person forced to perform inside a play, blurring when he is acting and when he is being himself. Together, this is all suggesting that a person has no single fixed self, but shifts across social masks and how others perceive them. It is used by Gellner to describe how entering psychoanalytic treatment can pull a person into a self-referential loop where analytical framing replaces everyday, external points of reference.
This all hearkens back to another interesting topic brought up early in this book: David Hume’s bundle theory of the self proposes that there is no fixed, permanent, or unified soul-like "self". Instead, what we call the "self" is merely a constantly shifting collection ("bundle") of transient perceptions, sensations, thoughts, and emotions.
View all my reviews